American Family Insurance- Jeff Finegan Agency LLCVerified Source

Insurance Sales Representative, Property & Casualty

Onsite · Columbus, Ohio
Posted August 12, 2026
payroll

Overview

You will own the full sales cycle for personal insurance policies, serving clients across Ohio through phone, email, and video. You will assess each client's coverage needs and recommend products that protect their assets. Join a tight-knit agency where your growth is fueled by hands-on training and a supportive team. This role offers a Monday-Friday schedule and the flexibility to work remotely, with a clear path to career advancement.

What You'll Do6

  • 1Sell insurance policies to clients using phone, email, and video conferencing.
  • 2Assess client insurance needs and recommend appropriate coverage options.
  • 3Process policy change requests and complete Evidence of Insurance requests.
  • 4Greet all customers entering the office with a friendly and helpful demeanor.
  • 5Take premium payments and verify contact details with each customer.
  • 6Return all phone messages promptly to ensure client satisfaction.

Requirements6

  • 11-3 years of experience working within an insurance agency.
  • 2Willingness to obtain a property and casualty license within 3 months of starting.
  • 3Active listening skills and the ability to build rapport quickly.
  • 4High self-motivation and a sense of urgency.
  • 5Excellent customer service skills and a positive attitude.
  • 6Proficiency with phone, email, and video conferencing tools.

Salary Insight

Salary not disclosed in listing

Location

Typeonsite
LocationColumbus, Ohio

Required Skills

phoneemailvideo conferencinginsurance salescustomer service
Share:

Similar open positions

Explore active roles that match your skills and interests.

Bill Palmer Insurance Inc

14h agoColumbus, Ohiopayroll

Insurance Customer Service Representative, Property & Casualty

As an Insurance Customer Service Representative, you own the full service lifecycle for existing and new clients at Bill Palmer Insurance, a full-service independent agency founded in 1977. You will manage renewals, generate quotes, and issue policies using Microsoft Word and Excel, while collaborating with a team of licensed agents. This role offers mentorship with an established agent and clear paths to advancement, with Ohio Property Casualty Insurance License support if needed. You will directly contribute to client retention and agency growth in a stable, locally trusted firm.

40K–55K
Customer ServiceCommunicationMicrosoft Word+3 more

Kashmiry & Associates, Inc.

14h agoColumbus, Ohiopayroll

Insurance Sales Representative, Life & Property

You will own new business production for a top-ranked agency in Columbus, Ohio. Sell life insurance and property insurance to clients across the state. Work alongside Real Estate Agents, Mortgage Lenders, and Title Companies to build your pipeline. This role rewards 100% commission plus base salary and bonuses. You will receive hands-on training and mentorship from a team ranked #1 nationwide.

35K–75K
life insuranceproperty insurancesales+2 more

EIG Insurance Center

14h agoWashington, District of Columbiapayroll

Insurance Sales Representative - Property & Casualty

You will own the full sales cycle for personal and commercial insurance products in our Waldorf, MD office. You will convert inbound leads into long-term clients by asking sharp questions and explaining coverage options in plain terms. You will work alongside a supportive agency team that values honest advice over high-pressure tactics. Your success will come from building trust, not pushing policies. This role rewards steady results and relationship-building over quick wins.

75K–125K
Active state insurance licenseSalesCustomer service+4 more

The King Allstate Agency Inc

14h agoPhiladelphia, Pennsylvaniapayroll

Insurance Sales Representative, Property & Casualty

You will own the full sales cycle, from first call to policy issuance, for personal lines insurance across PA, NJ, and DE. You will join a growing team at The King Allstate Agency in Glenside, PA, where you’ll spend your days on the phone with customers and prospects, helping them protect their assets. This role offers hands-on training and a clear path to career growth, with the chance to earn a Property & Casualty license and develop your sales skills in a supportive environment.

50K–80K
property & casualtysalescustomer relationship management+2 more

Weber Insurance Agency

14h agoPortland, Oregonpayroll

Licensed Insurance Sales Representative, Property and Casualty

You will own client relationships and drive sales growth for a local agency that values transparency and staff investment. With an active Oregon Property and Casualty License, you will build trust, tailor coverage, and close deals in a supportive environment. The team of 5 operates with a client-first mindset, backed by warm leads and full training. This role stands apart with base salary plus commission, weekends off, and clear paths to advancement.

54K–82K
insurancesalescrm+2 more

John Burroughs Agency

14h agoHouston, Texaspayroll

Insurance Sales Representative, Property & Casualty

You will own client acquisition and account management for John Burroughs Agency, an independent insurance agency with 30+ years in Houston, Texas. You will work alongside a team of sales agents, converting prospects into long-term customers through property and casualty insurance products. The role offers a base salary plus uncapped commission, with top performers earning significant bonuses. Unlike other agencies, John Burroughs provides full training for entry-level candidates, making this a launching point for a serious sales career.

35K–80K
propertycasualtycrm+2 more